After obtaining the Green Orb from the Queen of Nautica, head back to Lonalulu to find a man under the pier looking for help. Agree to assist him and search for his missing property.

The property in question is a Carved Figure that can be found by sailing north of Lonalulu to Insula Orientalis. Once docked, search along the short to the east to find the Carved Figure before Zooming back to Lonalulu to hand it over.