1 - Black Widow Spider
If you’ve finished Dutch’s item request from your camp, then you should know where this card is located. The town of Strawberry is located in the West Elizabeth state on the map and this card is to the northwest of that town. South of the Little Creek River is a main road that extends east to west. Look northeast of the "W" in West Elizabeth on the map to spy a small cottage, which is called Vetter’s Echo (name doesn’t display unless you’ve been there). The card is found on a desk inside of this small cabin, but if it’s your first time there, beware the bear inside.
2 - Bloodhound
The town of Rhodes can be found in the southeast section of the map and this card will be to the south of there. East of the "O" of the name Scarlett Meadows is a place called Bolger Blade. You should be able to spot a building on your map above that, which is actually a destroyed house. The card will be in the fireplace of this destroyed house.
3 - Blue Jay
Look for the name "New Hanover" stretched across the middle of the map, as this will be a clue for hunting down this card (and the Pheasant one, as they are in the same spot). Locate the "V" of New Hanover, which is northeast of Emerald Ranch. Head south from the "V" until you spot a cabin that has a fence and a tree next to it. The treee will have a ladder attached, leading up to a platform. You’ll find the card on a box at the top of the ladder (along with Pheasant, too).
4 - Catfish
This card can be found in Saint Denis, so head to the town and look for a dock to the west of the "Saint" on your map. It will be on a barrel.
5 - Coral Snake
North of Saint Denis is the bayou/swamp area and on the southern end of the lake there is a spot named "Lakay." Directly to the left of this location are some buildings on your map. Head inside the bigger of the two and you’ll find the card sitting on the table with a candle on it on the right side from where you entered.
6 - Grouper
Seems you need the Stranger Mission logged for this card to spawn. Locate Lagras north of Saint Denis and you should see some buildings just northwest of the name on the map. On the left side is a boat, so climb onto it and head up the ladder. Drop down to the backside of the boat and this card should be sitting on a barrel.
7 - Large Mouth Bass
Flatneck Station is southwest of your camp in Chapter 2 and there will be a coastline to the south of the station. Follow this coastline to the east until you spot a small house right on the water’s edge. Head inside and look underneath the couch on the side for the card.
8 - Panther
Southwest of the Van Horn Trading Post is a run-down fort north of where the Kamassa River is written on the map. Enter the fort and go inside the bigger building here to find the card sitting on a box.
9 - Parrot
This card is located in the swamp/bayou area north of Saint Denis. Where Lemoyne is written on the map, look just left of the "Y" to find a pier, where you’ll find the card sitting on a box.
10 - Pheasant
Look for the name "New Hanover" stretched across the middle of the map, as this will be a clue for hunting down this card (and the Pheasant one, as they are in the same spot). Locate the "V" of New Hanover, which is northeast of Emerald Ranch. Head south from the "V" until you spot a cabin that has a fence and a tree next to it. The treee will have a ladder attached, leading up to a platform. You’ll find the card on a box at the top of the ladder (along with Blue Jay, too).
11 - Snapping Turtle
Locate Cumberland Forest on the map, which is south of Fort Wallace, easily findable because it’s an off-limits area. In between the "O" and "R" of Forest, go south a little bit to find a house. Head inside of the house and look underneath a table to find a card sitting on a box; it’s the table next to the bed.
12 - Turkey
This one can be found in the Van Horn Trading Post on the eastern coast. On the southern end of the outpost, on the right side, there is a burnt down sheriff’s office. Head inside and go to the second floor, where you’ll find this card on the mantle above the fireplace.