Gamer Guides Review Score Guidelines & Explanations

Our editors’ pick for the standout release of the month.

Reserved for games that not only score highly, but also deliver something exceptional - genre-leading design, outstanding execution, or meaningful creative/technical impact.

Typically means

  • Sets a benchmark or meaningfully evolves its genre
  • Strong creative identity with confident execution
  • High polish and stability for its scope
  • Broadly recommendable and likely to have lasting impact

Most Recent Reviews

Star Fox 90 2026
Mina the Hollower 95 2026
Resident Evil 9: Requiem 96 2026
Cairn 95 2026
Octopath Traveler 0 85 2025
View More (40)

A landmark release with near-flawless execution.

Delivers best-in-class quality across design, polish, and player experience, with only negligible shortcomings. Often defines its year - and sometimes its genre.

Typically means

  • Exceptional craftsmanship across gameplay, systems, and content
  • Remarkable polish, stability, and attention to detail
  • Stands out even among Excellent-tier releases
  • Likely to be remembered long-term (awards/genre influence)

Most Recent Reviews

Mina the Hollower 95 2026
Resident Evil 9: Requiem 96 2026
Cairn 95 2026
Hades 2 96 2025
Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 98 2025
View More (12)

Exceptional quality with only minor shortcomings.

Delivers a consistently high-end experience across core areas (gameplay, design, presentation, performance, and polish). Any issues are small, situational, or easily outweighed by strengths.

Typically means

  • Strong, cohesive vision executed with confidence
  • High polish and stability for the game’s scope
  • Top-tier moment-to-moment play and/or standout artistry
  • Easy to recommend at full price for most players

Most Recent Reviews

Echoes of Aincrad 82 2026
Star Fox 90 2026
Devil May Cry 5 81 2026
007 First Light 82 2026
Forza Horizon 6 80 2026
View More (99)

A strong game with clear strengths and manageable flaws.

Competent but inconsistent. Worth considering for fans or at the right price, but shortcomings meaningfully affect the overall experience (pacing, repetition, balance, polish, or content value).

Typically means

  • Enjoyable and well-made overall, but not as consistently excellent - may play it safe, have some rough edges, or show gaps in pacing, depth, or technical polish.

Most Recent Reviews

The Adventures of Elliot: The Millennium Tales 75 2026
Gothic Remake 79 2026
Directive 8020 79 2026
Outbound 72 2026
Saros 74 2026
View More (70)

Mixed results - some good ideas, uneven execution.

Competent but inconsistent. Worth considering for fans or at the right price, but shortcomings meaningfully affect the overall experience (pacing, repetition, balance, polish, or content value).

Typically means

  • Clear positives alongside clear drawbacks
  • Inconsistency in quality, design clarity, or content depth
  • Technical issues may appear, but usually not catastrophic
  • Best approached with tempered expectations (often better on sale)

Most Recent Reviews

Crimson Desert 50 2026
Star Wars Outlaws 50 2024
Call of Duty: Modern Warfare III 50 2023
Gotham Knights 55 2022
Neverwinter Nights: Enhanced Edition 55 2020
View More (5)

Major problems overshadow the positives.

Frequent frustrations, missing polish, or weak design foundations significantly harm enjoyment. Only recommended for a very specific niche - and typically only after patches or at a deep discount.

Typically means

  • Regular disruption from bugs/performance/design issues
  • Underdeveloped systems, poor balance, or thin content
  • Limited value relative to price and competitors
  • Not recommended for most players in its current form

Most Recent Reviews

Yakuza Kiwami 3 & Dark Ties 20 2026
View More (1)

Not recommended.

Fails to meet basic standards of quality, stability, or coherent design. Severe issues make it difficult to enjoy or fairly evaluate as a complete experience.

Typically means

  • Serious stability/performance problems or broken progression
  • Fundamentally flawed or unfinished-feeling experience
  • Poor value even at a discount
  • Would require substantial fixes to become recommendable

Got feedback?

The fastest way to get in touch with us is to: join our Discord server

Share your thoughts: Send us your feedback

Pencil icon Sign up

Or

Guides

Updated Title Publisher

Maps

Updated Title Publisher

Databases

Updated Title

Reviews

Published Title Score Editor's Choice Publisher
Previews icon

Previews

Published Title Publisher
GG logo

Register to continue…

Already have an account?

Log in to continue…

Forgot?


Account Created

Select username: