A rather simple mission to get Chapter 2 started, speak to Uncle at the camp to begin. While in control of the wagon, follow the trail towards Valentine where you will come across another wagon out of control. Dismount from the Horse and head over to speak to the Coach driver who will ask for your assistance. Agree to help him and head over to the white horse, choosing to Calm it in the process. Once calmed, lead it back over to the driver to gain a boost to your Honor and return to your wagon.
Bring the wagon to a stop near the Stables in Valentine and the girls will head off on their own to snuff out some business. Follow Uncle to the General Store where you’ll get a tutorial on how they work. Although you can browse the shelves, it’s easier to just head to the counter and use the Catalog and purchase anything that may take your fancy. Once you’re finished with the shopping trip, head back outside to wait for the girls.
After Arthur and Uncle share a drink while waiting, a commotion will break out across the way with Tilly. Quickly head over to her and Defuse the situation to end it peacefully before heading into the nearby Hotel. You’ll have to be quick here, you only have 45 seconds to find Karen if you wish to obtain the Gold Medal so dart up the stairs and take a right at the top, entering Room 2B at the end to find Karen being assaulted. Knock the man out using melee attacks and then follow Karen back down the stairs and outside.
Before you can head back, a man spots Arthur from Blackwater and takes off on his horse. Gallop after him, heading through the stables in the process and eventually the man will fall off his horse and dangle from the cliff edge. Choose to help the man up in order to increase your Honor and you’ll obtain a Pen as way of thanks.