This mystery can be found in the centre of Hamtunscire, at Heald Tor, just north of the city of Wincestre. When you arrive at the location you’ll find a man named Kenrick standing beneath a cliff. Speak with him to begin the mystery.
Retrieve the Arrow for Kenrick
Kenrick will inform you that he wants to get an arrow from the cliff edge above. The arrow was put there by the father of a woman who Kenrick wants to marry. Unfortunately for him, many others have tried to obtain the arrow and have failed. It now becomes your task to climb to the top of the cliff and retrieve the arrow for Kenrick.
When you reach the top of the cliff, you’ll find a lynx waiting in ambush. Kill the lynx and then read the letter on the ground. The letter details the fact that the daughter does not want to marry Kenrick. At this point you could choose not to get the arrow, but you will fail the mystery if you don’t. Take the arrow and bring it to Kenrick. You will have two dialogue options here, but both lead to the same outcome.